When I became an elementary school librarian, I inherited a collection of books that had been organized by someone else. Books were put in YA based on someone's thoughts on what should be strictly for grade 7 & 8 students. If students want to read these books, they need to be a certain age or they need permission from their parents to 'shop' anywhere in the library.
So while this book is BRILLIANT, the thought of putting it my library gives me anxiety. I'm usually fine with some mature language and questionable content. I feel like if a kid can find the f bomb or the adult content, I'm happy because they are reading! However, the mature content and language is really out there in this book. But the book is so great! What's a librarian to do? I feel like author, Jesse Andrews has perfectly captured the spirit of most teenage boys.
There is no searching for salacious tidbits, this book hits you over the head with them. But did I laugh out loud? Oh ya! It is so funny. If you ever struggled socially at all during high school, you will identify in more than one way to the trials of Greg.
At it's heart, this book is revealing and touching even though Greg claims to be untouched by the sickness and eventual death of Rachel (not a spoiler, as per the title). He claims over and over again that he is unaffected and learns nothing from the experience:
And then we sat and didn't say anything for awhile. You're probably hoping I was sitting there overflowing with love and tenderness. Maybe you should think about switching to a different book. Even to, like an owner's manual to a refrigerator or something. That would be more heartwarming than this.
I politely and firmly disagree. What Greg does is underline how difficult it is to deal with a friend who is dying, but in his discomfort and awkwardness we are drawn to his endearing way of befriending Rachel. He doesn't say the right things and it's a little painful at times (actually it's hilarious) but the realness is refreshing. We so often read about kids who do the right things and say exactly what needs to be said. That's not real life! Who EVER knows what to say in times like these? There's nothing you can say to make it all better. Thanks Greg Gaines for keeping it real and making me laugh out loud - Something that rarely happens in my reading.